Choosing the right creatine gummy in Australia isn’t as simple as it looks. Recent industry scrutiny has highlighted how some products fail to deliver the creatine content they claim, raising serious questions around transparency, dosing accuracy, and trust.
To cut through the noise, we’ve compared the four most prominent creatine gummy brands currently available in Australia that are selling legitimate creatine products. Each brand is assessed side-by-side so you can make an informed decision based on facts, not marketing.
Our review is grounded in independent lab testing (where available), verified customer feedback, cost per gram of creatine, overall reputation and official brand disclosures — giving you a clear picture of what you’re actually getting in each gummy.
TLDR; see the table below
Without further ado, here is the full breakdown of Australia’s best creatine gummies:
1. CreaMax
CreaMax has built its brand around a "no-BS, full transparency" approach for the most reliable option in Australia. Being one of the first to build around prioritising verified dosing and local third-part testing, effectively setting the new “gold standard” for transparency.
-
Background: Founded specifically to deliver trustworthy creatine gummies when the market was even more riddled with fakes.
-
Key Advantages: High transparency; third party lab tested in Australia. Uses 1g dosing for easy tracking. Well-liked flavours with options to have sweeter gummies with sugar, or less sweet gummies without.
-
Subscriptions: Available with no lock-in contract.
-
Price: From $53.99 for a 120-gummy jar on subscription with free shipping.
-
Creatine per gummy: 1 gram.
-
Taste Profile: Two options: Pineapple (subtle and natural) and Mixed Berry (sweeter and lolly-like).
-
Reviews: Highly positive regarding texture and long-term use (4.9/5 stars). Users often mention they don't get sick of the flavour over months of use.
-
Shortfalls: Each gummy contains 1 gram of creatine which is excellent for tailorability of dosage. However, if you are taking 5 grams per day every day, this will make the gummies run out 20% faster than other brands selling gummies with 1.25 grams.
-
Trustworthiness/Reputation: Excellent. Known as the "gold standard" for transparency in the Australian gummy space. Third-party batch tested in Australia with results available on website. Ambassador team of 10+ Australian fitness professionals.
2. Cunnies Gummies
Cunnies is the "loud" brand of the group. Founded by polarising internet personality - Adam Sullivan - they lean heavily into the bold experience, offering an intense sour and sweet flavour profile.
-
Background: A lifestyle-focused supplement brand that gained massive traction through Adam Sullivan’s personal brand.
-
Key Advantages: The most "treat-like" experience if you enjoy sour confectionary; high dosage per serving.
-
Subscriptions: Available with a lock-in contract.
-
Price: From $58.46 for a 120 gummy bag on lock-in subscription (+$9.95 shipping).
-
Creatine per gummy: 1.25 grams (5g per 4-gummy serving).
-
Taste Profile: Incredibly bold, sweet, and sour. The sour range reportedly tastes like your average sour lolly from a corner store with a bit more of an artificial sweetener aftertaste. These are the strongest tasting of the group which some people love, and others find difficult to take daily.
-
Reviews: Cunnies Gummmies does not publish any customer reviews making it difficult to gauge. Some users reportedly love the initial taste, but some find them "too much" for a daily habit.
-
Issues: The strong flavours can be offputting when trying to take the creatine every day. The lock-in contracts and higher price points also make Cunnies a less affordable option. 1.25 grams per gummy also makes tailoring dosage more difficult if less than 5g daily is required.
-
Trustworthiness/Reputation: Strong but polarising. The brand entered the market following the “fake creatine” scandals and emphasizes transparency, providing overseas third-party batch test results online. Adam Sullivan’s personal brand, marked by bold, provocative content, draws a devoted following, though it also generates criticism, leaving the brand both loved and disliked depending on the audience.
3. Push Gummies
Push was a pioneer in the space but found itself at the centre of the James Smith debunking scandal. Lab tests originally showed their product contained barely a fraction of the advertised creatine. They have since reformulated, but the brand has been damaged.
-
Background: One of the original "OG" Australian gummy brands that faced significant backlash in early 2025 due to false label claims.
-
Key Advantages: Now reformulated to meet label claims.
-
Subscriptions: Offered, though many previous subscribers have moved to other brands following the scandal.
-
Price: From $47.20 per 120 gummy bag on subscription (+$8.90 shipping).
-
Creatine per gummy: 1.25 grams
-
Taste Profile: Recently changed. While they were previously praised for taste (back when they contained essentially no creatine), the new "legit" formula has a texture that some users find less appealing.
-
Reviews: Mixed. Recent reviews suggest the new flavour and texture is unpleasant, and most customers are still wary of the brand's history.
-
Issues: Heavy reputational damage; the new formula’s texture and taste is reportedly "hit or miss" for long-term fans. 1.25 grams per gummy also makes tailoring dosage more difficult if less than 5g daily is required.
-
Trustworthiness/Reputation: Damaged. They are working hard to win back trust with new lab reports, but have a long way to go before being considered trustworthy.
4. SUP Gummies
SUP is the "Mainstream" option. You’ll find them in Chemist Warehouse, Coles, and Woolworths, making them the most accessible for anyone nearby.
-
Background: A large-scale supplement company that produces a wide range of vitamins and performance gummies for the retail market.
-
Key Advantages: Ultimate convenience; you can buy them with your groceries.
-
Subscriptions: Not easily accessible.
-
Price: RRP of $27.00 for a 35-pack.
-
Creatine per gummy: 1 gram.
-
Taste Profile: Flavours Cola and Peach are typically regarded to be nice tasting, but are often criticised for their high sugar content and sugar coating.
-
Reviews: Typically positive towards flavour, while many express concerns over high sugar content and lacking value-for-money.
-
Issues: The most expensive per gram. At $27 for only 35g of creatine, you are paying a massive premium for the convenience of retail availability. It is almost double the cost per serve as the other options on this list.
-
Trustworthiness/Reputation: Solid. Being a major retail brand, they undergo standard Australian regulatory checks, though they aren't as vocal about independent batch testing.
The Verdict: Which Gummy is for You?
For the one chasing transparency, good taste & results
CreaMax is the winner here. They've positioned themselves as the most transparent go to in Australia. Providing people with verified dosing, clear consistency and local third-part testing. This makes them a go-to when choosing gummies - even when offering flexible dosages, and sugar free options letting you choose what's best for you.
For the one who prioritises bold flavours and excitement
Cunnies are your best bet. If you genuinely want your supplement to feel like it takes you back to your childhood, or if you just love Adam Sullivan, these will be your best bet.
For the ones who choose convenience over everything
SUP is perfect if you run out and can't wait for shipping. It’s expensive in the long run, but reliable and easy to find at the chemist.